Arguments against the Death Penalty You are here: Arguments against the Death… The idea of putting another human to death is hard to completely fathom. The physical mechanics involved in the act of execution are easy to grasp, but the emotions involved in carrying out a death sentence on another person, regardless of how much they deserve it, is beyond my own understanding.
The most heinous of crimes are subject to the highest form of punishment — death penalty.
Capital punishment has its share of supporters who believe in the merits of death penalty in fighting crime. On the other side of the coin are those who view the punishment as unconstitutional, barbaric, and just plain cruel.
Many believe that the perpetrators deserve maximum penalty and the highest condemnation of all. This is clearly an emotional response, but it raises the question of whether death penalty is an effective way to deter prospective criminals. This essay aims to show two sides of the issue and argue that death penalty does not necessarily deter criminals from committing future crimes.
The main argument in support of death penalty is its perceived deterrent effect. In his study on deterrence in support of death penalty, van den Haag acknowledges that even though statistical results are inconclusive, capital punishment is likely to deter people from committing crimes because of fear of death, and more so if it is a death ordered by law.
He states that death penalty permanently incapacitates the offender from committing future crimes. He highlights that it is the most feared form of punishment and because of its finality, it could deter prospective murderers who are not deterred by long-term imprisonment.
He also puts more weight on saving the lives of prospective victims rather than preserving the lives of convicted murderers who may re-offend. Based on their two controversial studies, they conclude that for each execution, five murders are prevented.
Conversely, one commutation results in five murders.
While statistics appear to strengthen the argument in favor of death penalty, they are just numbers that do not support actual crime rates. However, the strongest arguments are those that criticized the studies for their faulty methodologies, insufficient data and flawed assumptions Liptak, The studies attempt to link executions with murder rate changes over time.
They ask whether executions made a difference in the crime rate at a given period. While this is a valid research question, studies fail to take into account other variables that have direct effect on crime rate such as the effectiveness of the judicial system, demographic changes, and economic conditions.
Critics add that the findings are skewed by data from a few jurisdictions, largely from Texas, hence, it is not representative of national data Liptak, With so few actual executions, the data is thin and conclusions derived from it are considered weak and misleading. In conclusion, it would be safe to say that there is no clear and indisputable evidence to suggest that the death penalty is an effective means to deter people from committing crimes or murderers from killing again.
The ambiguous results of studies make the deterrence argument weak. They are not enough to justify executions.The death penalty or capital punishment is a controversial topic that many people like to ignore, or put on the back burner.
The death penalty is a sentence, while capital punishment is the actual execution. It is wrong and immoral. In extreme crime cases where the death penalty would be considered. Capital punishment has its share of supporters who believe in the merits of death penalty in fighting crime.
On the other side of the coin are those who view the . Jul 08, · Capital Punishment - Retain or Not? This essay tangles with the question of whether or not we should retain the death penalty within the American code of penal law.
- Capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime.
The judicial decree that someone be punished in this manner is a death sentence, while the actual process of killing the person is an execution. Example academic essay: The Death Penalty. This essay shows many important features which commonly appear in essays.
Should the death penalty be restored in the UK? The restoration of the death penalty for serious crimes is an issue of debate in the UK because of . Death penalty is capital punishment wherein a criminal proven guilty of a major crime is sentenced to death by the government.
I am against the death penalty and can prove in my essay that abolishing it would be a better choice.